It is sickening how many people, self-professed libertarians the lot of them, think prostitution should be legalized. What is most shocking about this claim is that so many people think it will somehow magically limit and relegate itself to fully consenting legal adults.
Riiiiight. So you actually think that a business that toils in the treating human beings like chattel, slaves, worse than physical property, will stop when they see a child being forced into this?
<ohh well they are consenting adults.> And you think the propagators will pull their own leashes, enact their own checks and balances, and make sure they will not toe the line of the law?
Wrong. What happens in reality is that you give them an inch, and they walk all over you.
Gradually, gradually breaking down the barriers of respect, decency, morals, humanity.
So many self-proclaimed libertarians and others claim that they are 100 percent in favor of consenting adults doing whatever they want, and that if anyone does not consent to doing this, this any one person can "just say no" and this is all the effort needed to keep herself (or himself) safe. Faux-libertarians are under the impression that simply a written law on a government ledger book is all that is needed for people to act in a moral manner. I am stunned that they honestly think rampant prostitution can blaze all within a population -- and that people will suddenly halt themselves at encountering a victim under age 18 who is forced into rape for profit by her abusive caretakers.
Libertarians pride themselves on their wisdom, their awareness of reality, on their enlightened yet supposedly practical stance on social issues, on their realistic expectations of human behavior. They manage to conveniently ignore the fact that the above scenario never works out this way in real life and is only wishful thinking.
Let us look to other analogies that have happened. Prohibition didn't work out that way. Abstinence-based sex education didn't work.
This has already happened with prostitution. First off, let us call it what it truly is. It is not "sex trade," "sex slaves," etc. or any other euphemistic soft-sounding drivel that hides the true gruesome reality. it is rape. That is what it is.
Feh, typical libertarian assholery. Geez, where do I even begin. I found it quite entertaining that you equated "employment opportunity" and "freedom" to getting fucked for cash.
Big factual error: libertarianism is not the same as capitalism. Libertarians do not favor capitalism. They favor robber barons- mega-corporations torturing the middle class.
And you even made the classic libertarian move of insisting that prostitution is no different from poorly-paid manual unskilled labor. Here is the difference- one is a matter of personal morals, the other is not.
The biggest problem with libertarians (who often by pure chance tend to be atheist) is that they cannot comprehend the abstract, critical-thinking concept of morality as separate from belief in a god figure. They are very much like religious zealots in this way.
Morals have to do with logic, reasoning, empathy, compassion for fellow human beings. But like most libertarians, you think that because you do not belong to a deity, this excuses you from any moral obligation, much less seeing other human beings as anything more than sacks of bones and meat.
Sigh. I don't know why I waste my time. Libertarians are a lost cause.